« Storage Encryption -- New Capabilities | Main | FCoE Gets Buzz At SNW »

April 14, 2008

Comments

Scott Quick

Great post. Makes you wonder if Aberdeen was trying to curry favor with EMC for follow-on work ;-) Nonetheless and as you mention, analysts still play a valuable roll - IF they avoid the preordained conclusions you mentioned.

alan pelz-sharpe

As far as I know CMS Watch is the only truly independent analyst firm in the business (we never consult to vendors, we don't write white papers, speak at vendor events - we pay our own travel and expenses, we don't even accept a meal from a vendor etc). Other do a good job too such as Burton Group - but its very very unusual for analyst firms not to be heavily dependent on vendor money.
Aberdeen represents the worst elements of the analyst industry in many peoples eyes (read the WSJ exposes of their practices) - so its highly unusual and frankly hard to believe that there was no vendor funding or involvement at all in the report you mention - if it is true then maybe there is hope.
But its a double edged sword Chuck - vendors (EMC included) buy analyst subscription services and consulting - and this gives the AR managers immense leverage over the analysts - heavily influencing or stopping any negative or critical output. Sad but true.
For truly independent researchers there is no financial leverage - but there are other means to twist the arm, via restriction of access to execs or refusal to provide briefings or fact checking etc.
The analyst community and the vendor AR community is in desperate need of a thorough overhaul - and like you I think we would all benefit as a result.
Best
Alan

The comments to this entry are closed.

Chuck Hollis


  • Chuck Hollis
    SVP, Oracle Converged Infrastructure Systems
    @chuckhollis

    Chuck now works for Oracle, and is now deeply embroiled in IT infrastructure.

    Previously, he was with VMware for 2 years, and EMC for 18 years before that, most of them great.

    He enjoys speaking to customer and industry audiences about a variety of technology topics, and -- of course -- enjoys blogging.

    Chuck lives in Vero Beach, FL with his wife and four dogs when he's not traveling. In his spare time, Chuck is working on his second career as an aging rock musician.

    Warning: do not ever buy him a drink when there is a piano nearby.

    Note: these are my personal views, and aren't reviewed or approved by my employer.
Enter your Email:
Preview | Powered by FeedBlitz

General Housekeeping

  • Frequency of Updates
    I try and write something new 1-2 times per week; less if I'm travelling, more if I'm in the office. Hopefully you'll find the frequency about right!
  • Comments and Feedback
    All courteous comments welcome. TypePad occasionally puts comments into the spam folder, but I'll fish them out. Thanks!